바로가기메뉴

본문 바로가기 주메뉴 바로가기

The Review of Korean Studies

South Korean Nationhood and Chinese Nationhood: An Ethno-Symbolic Account

The Review of Korean Studies / The Review of Korean Studies, (P)1229-0076; (E)2773-9351
2005, v.8 no.2, pp.141-152

  • Downloaded
  • Viewed

Abstract

This paper contrasts the Korean ethnic-centered understanding of nationhood with the Chinese state-centered understanding. This paper also explains this contrast in a historical context. By so doing, this paper makes an effort to elaborate on Anthony Smith’s ethno-symbolic account of nationhood, in which he balances the influence of the ethnic past with the impact of nationalist activities. Both Korea and China followed a similar Confucian tradition and started to build their nation-states under the threat of colonization by Western powers in the late 19th century. However, these two countries had different ethnic pasts and, thus, respectively adopted different concepts of nationhood during their nation-building processes. As a result, Koreans and Chinese hold almost opposite understandings of nationhood today.

keywords
Korea, China, nationhood, ethnic-centered, state-centered, Korea, China, nationhood, ethnic-centered, state-centered

Reference

1.

Contemporary China, Edited by B,

2.

Cha Seokgi , (1999) Hanguk minjokjuui gyoyukui saengseong gwa jeongae (The,

3.

origin and development of Korean nationalist education,

4.

Choe Hyun, (2003) National Identity and Citizenship in China and Korea,

5.

Irvine, University of California,

6.

Chow, Kai-wing, (1997) Imagining Boundaries of Blood: Zhang Binglin and the,

7.

Invention of the Han ‘Race’ in Modern China In The construction of racial,

8.

identities in China and Japan,

9.

London, edited by F, Hurst & Company Ltd

10.

Christie, Clive J, (1998) Race and nation: a reader, Tauris history readers. New,

11.

Chun, (1996) From Nationalism to Nationalizing Cultural Imagination,

12.

and State Formation in Postwar Taiwan, In Chinese nationalism

13.

Crossley, (1999) A translucent mirror: history and identity in Qing,

14.

imperial ideology, University of California Press,

15.

Cumings, (1997) Korea’s Place in the Sun: A Modern History. , New York:

16.

Duara, , (1996) De-Constructing the Chinese Nation, In Chinese

17.

Unger, edited by J,

18.

Cambridge, Published for the Korea Institute Harvard University by,

19.

Ilchokak; Distributed by Harvard University Press,

20.

Em, (1999) Minjok as a Modern and Democratic Construct: Sin,

21.

In Colonial Modernity in Korea edited by G,

22.

Fitzgerald, (1963) The Chinese View of Foreign Relations,

23.

He,Yingjie, , (1999) Reimaging the Chinese Nation: The,

24.

Eric J, (1990) Nation and Nationalism since 1780,

25.

Late Qing-Republican Crisis, In China’s quest for national identity,

26.

Karl, Rebecca E, (2002) Staging the World: Chinese Nationalism at the Turn of,

27.

In China’s quest for national identity edited by L,

28.

Lee Jeanyoung, (1999) China’s Policy towards the Korean Minority in China,

29.

(1945-1995) Department of Sociology The London School of Economics,

30.

London, University of London,

31.

Park Myoung-Kyu, (1998) Geundae hanggukui taja insikui byeonhwawa minjokjeongcheseong,

32.

The Change of Ideas of Others and National Identity in,

33.

Sautman,, (1997) Myths of descent, descent, racial nationalism and ethnic minorities,

34.

in the People’s Republic of China In The construction of racial identities,

35.

Franz, (1968) Ideology and organization in Communist China,

36.

Berkeley, University of California Press,

37.

Shin Gi-wook, (1999) The politics of ethnic,

38.

Nations, nationalism in divided Korea,

39.

(1979) Sin Chaeho [Selected works of Sin Chaeho], Sin Chaeho

40.

Smith, (2000) The nation in history: historiographical debates about,

41.

University Press of New England,

42.

The Academy of Korean Studies, (2002) Hanguk minjok munhwa sajeon,

43.

Encyclopedia of Korean Culture,

44.

The Academy of Korean Studies,

45.

Weber, Essays in sociology, Oxford university press

46.

Paper read at, History Education and History Textbooks in China,

47.

History Education and History Textbooks in Globalization,

48.

Zheng,Yongnian. , (1999) Discovering Chinese Nationalism in China,

The Review of Korean Studies